Retrospect: On Questioning

Our Philosophical Happy Hour (2 September 2026) focused on the art of questioning—and precisely how we have come, wrongly, to expect answers today.  Here is a reflection on what was discussed. These brief reflections are structured principally around four questions asked: first, concerning the evaluation of propositions the content of which are not immediately evident…

|

|

Our Philosophical Happy Hour (2 September 2026) focused on the art of questioning—and precisely how we have come, wrongly, to expect answers today.  Here is a reflection on what was discussed.

These brief reflections are structured principally around four questions asked: first, concerning the evaluation of propositions the content of which are not immediately evident to sense; second, concerning the “phases” of life and their conditions; third, a question on the art of questioning itself; and fourth, a question on cybernetics (most specifically, feedback loops). 

As was the point of our session, we saw how any answer that could be given to each question would presume answers to other, larger, more comprehensive questions.

1. Evaluating the Truth

First concerning the evaluation of propositions to content of which are not immediately evident to sense: this is a difficult issue that we might situate within “logic”, broadly understood—that is, what the Scholastics called “material logic” and which modernity calls “epistemology”, but which we might today recognize as a certain question of semiotics.  Whereas propositions such as “The couch is red” can be solved, first by any sufficiently well-functioning eyes and second by a spectrometer which reports on the wavelengths reflected by the couch under ordinary light, other propositions do not give us so clean an opportunity for resolution.  For instance, saying, “The law is just”—a law might be articulated in language, but the law itself cannot be sensed; and justice, most certainly, does not reduce to anything corporeal.

Can both kinds of proposition be assessed through the same means?  One, today especially, may be inclined to look for universal categories and methods in assessing the truth of any and every claim.  But while there are undoubtedly methods for assessing the truth of the claim that a given law is or is not just, it cannot be the same as that employed in assessing whether a couch is red.  The methods, that is, must follow from the differences in the things themselves.  Every measure is, in some sense, derived from the thing measured and must therefore the method must be adapted to the thing itself as its own ultimate measure

Logic may be an instrument or tool, but, like the hand, must conform itself to the governing reality, rather than vice versa.

2. Evaluating Social Norms and Conditions

Second, concerning the idea of life’s phases: in general, and for quite a long time (at least in this country), life has generally been regarded to consist in three primary phases, with respect specifically to our occupations: first, a preparatory period, lasting through the attainment of an education; second, and what is generally regarded as the principal part of one’s life, that of career—of productivity, contribution, accomplishment; and third and finally, a period of retirement—formerly expected not to last more than a few years, but growing ever longer as means of supporting health and longevity improve.  As the questioner put it, to paraphrase, the structure seemingly makes less sense, works less well, the longer that people live; a prolonged retirement increases everyone’s burden.

In a way, this question intersected with the third and fourth—concerning the art of questioning and the mechanism of feedback loops as supposedly explanatory for behavior and action, especially of human beings.

For each, albeit in rather different ways, asks a fundamental question about the order of living.  With respect to the “phases” of life, it seems that the structure—educated and prepared into one’s adulthood (late teens? Early 20s?  Late 20s?), work for 40 or so years, then retire until you die—stands on the premise that our lives are governed by the quality, and especially the economic productivity, of our middle years, and that what happens after they have finished does not much matter.

We lapse into these norms and conditions of life as though a settled matter.  Are they?  Should they be?

3. Evaluating Our Own Lives

That is to say: many people have, especially in the past few centuries, found life’s purpose—at least, its daily ordering—in or through their work and its immediate consequences.  This “given” seems today thrown into question: work, especially work which appears meaningful, may not be available for us, ready-to-hand, so as to constitute a genuine purpose.  Does that leave us needing to create one, to invent one where none is to be found?

A bigger question thus emerges: what do we really mean by a purpose for life, for living?  How do we discern the elements of such a purpose, whether in what we find ready-made or in what we discern from out of our own faculties?

Here we ought perhaps to throw into question the whole “system” we have inherited.  I myself have long been arguing against the idea of education, for instance, as merely preparatory for the rest of life—an error that I believe has left many confronting retirement with a kind of foreboding.  Pleasure activities like golf, or going down to the club, reading novels by the pool—these are no lasting satisfaction in old age, only a kind of distraction while waiting to die.  Is retirement an age of meaningless existence, then?

Or should it not, perhaps, be a time reserved wholly for true leisure?  This requires us to understand what leisure truly is, in what it most truly consists—and why it is not something merely to pass the time, but to give meaning and purpose and indeed structure to all the rest of our living.

—

A brief recommended reading list: Pieper, Leisure: The Basis of Culture and In Defense of Philosophy; Plato—in all his works, but perhaps most specifically with respect to this questioning of questions, the Apology and the Meno.

Leave a Reply

Recent writing