What allows us to understand one another? What makes a “culture” to be common? Shared beliefs, practices, and experiences—or something more fundamental to our humanity? Join our Philosophical Happy Hour (11/18/26) to discuss.
A very good friend of mine—an intelligent, insightful, and articulate fellow—insists that Edmund Husserl is a realist. We have read most of the same texts. We took many of the same classes in graduate school. And yet I cannot see how he has arrived at his interpretation.
Undoubtedly, we all have had similar experiences: encounters where, despite seeming to share much in common with another, we find a particular point of seeming irreconcilable divergence. In recent years, it seems the frequency and depth of these divergences has grown. Commonalities disintegrating before our eyes. Where once, a common culture seemed to contain our disagreements, today, they seem to drive us farther and farther apart.
Culture and Shared Interpretation
In my own approach to attempting an answer at the question of culture, a few ideas stand out as necessary. One group of such ideas can be found in Aristotle’s Poetics. That is, to speak of “culture”, we have to be able to identify plots or narratives as construed though action and language. There are actions that signify a cultured soul; there are words that signify a barbaric one. Each kind of soul belongs within, and comes to shape, the narrative not only of the individual life but also the lives affected by it.
Similarly, it seems that education is an idea inseparable from that of culture. A human soul does not, of itself and automatically, produce a culture. Rather, “culture” results only from discovering, understanding, and communicating the governing rationales uncovered through strenuous intellectual inquiry. Other conventions might be passed from person to person, shared among groups, used in a way to bind together many persons—but are they really what we mean by “culture”?
That is, I would distinguish between a shared interpretation or understanding and a common reaction. The latter might signify tribal identity, and therein might lie something we identify as cultural… but, perhaps, by equivocating on the term.
Commonality because of Disagreement?
What brings us to attain a truly shared interpretation or understanding? I think it is a necessary constituent of what we mean by the term “culture”, as something common or shared amongst a multitude of people. But… we might, at the same time, mistake the common reactivity for signifying a culture as well. If I walk into the Buffalo Bills stadium on a game day, for instance—a long-storied NFL franchise with a very passionate fanbase—while wearing my Kansas City Chiefs’ attire, and start shouting about how the Bills have never won a Super Bowl, how they went 0-4 in four consecutive years, I am certain to get a common reaction from their fans. So too, if I went to a MAGA rally (c.2024, at least) and started denouncing everything Trump, or went to a “Free Palestine” march and praised Israel, common reactions would undoubtedly come hurtling at me vehemently.
Such conflict ordinarily has one and only one resolution: namely, force. But other conflicts, it seems, are necessary to produce the shared interpretation necessary for a common culture’s possibility: namely, the conflicts of intellectual disagreement; conflicts that arise through challenging the articulations put forward by others. Without such challenge, it seems each person will fold inevitably back in upon himself, into an environment of unthinking and unchallenged isolation. He will never see or discover anything but the already-seen or already-discovered.
Culture through Conversation
Of course, this raises the very good question: how do we actually come to see things the same way? Must we have a common environment? A similar background? The same beliefs? Chosen aims? It seems harder and harder, in our digitally-permeated lives, to find two persons who truly reside in the same world. But perhaps, I might suggest, the pre-digital sameness held in common was often shallow—and that we can, indeed must, do better.
So please, whether you agree or disagree, join our Philosophical Happy Hour this Wednesday (18 November 2026, from 5:45-7:15+ pm ET) as we contemplate the attainment of shared interpretations and formation of common culture:
- What is an interpretation? How can it be shared? With others?
- What distinguishes culture from convention? What distinguishes the two?
- How do narratives, actions, and the use of language contribute to “culture”? What is the role of stories, rituals, and their reception by people of every age?
- What is the role that disagreement plays in the constitution of a shared interpretation? How should we think about disagreement in our conversations, relationships, etc.? Do they need to exist on some prior common ground? How is that ground discovered, shared?
Open to the public
Philosophical Happy Hour
Join a meaningful public conversation every Wednesday, 5:45–7:15 p.m. ET.



Leave a Reply