On the serious thinker in the digital age: moving past the narrow paradigms of the “elite”.
Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, Dartmouth, Cornell, Brown, Pennsylvania; MIT, Stanford, Caltech, Chicago, Duke, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, Carnegie Mellon: the Ivy League and their top rival institutions.[1] To attend and excel in these schools—as a student or professor—has long been almost a prerequisite for joining the nation’s “intellectual elite”. Other institutions may join the conversation, of course; but seldom for long, if at all, do they dictate its course. Government, thinktanks, and tech industries today too still rank high in influence, of course.[2]
But what if all this jockeying for status, power, and influence has come to undermine rather than accelerate the intellectual life? What if, rather than making serious persons, our “elite” have taken a serious pursuit—thinking together in institutions dedicated to the purpose—and turned it into a cloak for their own vanity?
I suspect this has long been a common problem of intellectually-formative institutions. But, while there remain good persons within these hallowed halls, the institutions themselves today seem, with respect to serious learning, largely hollowed out: disdainful of tradition and captured by the image of success.
Indeed, for centuries, those possessing the wealth or access to it have also held the means to serious intellectual pursuit. But the digital age has begun dissolving this grasp, and serious persons of every economic status—including those once excluded not for want of ability but only of opportunity—may turn elsewhere, now, to find a real intellectual formation. This turn is already resulting in the emergence of a new, genuine class of intellectuals: those distinguished not by the prestige of their alma maters or employers, but by the quality of their thinking.
1. Retrieving the Intellect
What is intelligence? The word has been used in many different ways over the centuries. Prior to modernity, it was understood as something specifically human: a kind of cognition that transcended the world of sense to deal with ideas. By the twentieth century, however, many persons came to use it for signifying a relatively narrow concept: namely, the recognition, analysis, and creative reconfiguration of patterns. These patterns might concern sensible phenomena or the interrelation of ideas and their means of representation. But regardless of the objects intended, key to this pattern-oriented activity of cognition was speed. Technologies of the twentieth century sped up human communication. This has had profound and often unrealized effects on us. As Marshall McLuhan wrote in his 1964 work Understanding Media:[3]
…the technological extension of our central nervous system that we call the electric media began more than a century ago, subliminally. Subliminal have been the effects. Subliminal they remain. At no period in human culture have men understood the psychic mechanisms involved in invention and technology. Today it is the instant speed of electric information that, for the first time, permits easy recognition of the patterns and the formal contours of change and development. The entire world, past and present, now reveals itself to us like a growing plant in an enormously accelerated movie. Electric speed is synonymous with light and with the understanding of causes. So, with the use of electricity in previously mechanized situations, men easily discover causal connections and patterns that were quite unobservable at the slower rates of mechanical change.
Many threads of inquiry can be traced from this passage. But let us stick with the relationship between speed and patterns. On the one hand, it is true that speed has helped us better to unveil the patterns by which things are causally constituted—at least, in part. As an example, consider digital traffic analytics. We can not only observe patterns with a certain informational precision, but analyze why they occur: correlating with advertisements, interactions, engagements, time of day, topic, etc. An ability for someone to quickly analyze such data—amidst television, radio, and the early stages of the internet—made that someone very valuable. Schools and universities ordered much of their education towards conformity with the electric speed up into the paradigm of pattern-oriented “intelligence”. One excelled at elite institutions by being an elite agent with respect to the understanding of such patterns.
But, on the other hand, the technological speed up quickly seems to be outpacing that ability. In other words, our tools increasingly seem capable of recognizing, analyzing, and reconfiguring those patterns. AI does this better than the human being. This has led many to think that AI has intelligence, and that “General” or “Super” machine intelligence is just around the corner, if not already here.
Yet I think this shows not that AI is intelligent, but that this narrow paradigm misconstrues intelligence and the intellects to which it belongs. A computer might “reckon”—to use the language of Brian Cantwell Smith—but it cannot truly make a “judgment”. Or, putting it in my own words, the reality of human intelligence includes but does not reduce to its discernment and evaluation of patterns. A mind that moves quickly from one to another object and quickly discerns the relationship of their interaction might be very skilled at navigating the complex world of fast-changing situations. But there is a different virtue which dwells on the particular, so that it may, in understanding it deeply, grasp the truth of something universal—something irreducible to any pattern.
The mind possessing cleverness proves itself useful. The contemplative thinker, on the other hand, tends to be “useless”; which is to say, someone whose intelligence is not put in service to something else, but which attains a good beyond value. Such insight tends nevertheless to benefit all our lives, that is, but because the good that it attains is a good that diffuses itself through order. To practice this contemplative mode, however, one must have not only the cleverness that successfully and quickly navigates the electric paradigm of rapidly-changing patterns, but more so patience, humility, honesty, a willingness to err and be corrected, and a habit of dogged perseverance in questioning.
These characteristics, it seems to me, build an enduring habit of genuine intellectual seriousness. Cleverness, whether purely natural or benefitted through training, does not alone make someone a serious thinker. That we tend to praise clever people follows more the fact that profits and technological advance, to which cleverness is useful, drives more concern than does the insight and understanding derived from intellectual seriousness. Notably, cleverness does little if anything to prevent its possessors from slipping into grave miscalculations and destructive behavior: fraud, deceit, infidelity, pride. Are these not contraindicators of intelligence? Contrariwise, while an intellectual life may not make one wealthy—indeed, it might stand in the way of wealth—I would argue it makes one more fully human. I might be able to make a large difference in my wealth by working an extra hour each day. But that material gain may not be worth the cost it has to not only my personal relationships, or my health, but so too the care for my mind.
As the environment undergoes yet another technological shift, intellectual formation must too. We do not need more merely clever persons adept at discriminating what appears. We need, rather, persons committed to seeking an understanding of what is; to asking the harder questions which take longer to answer; to ask questions not by matching them with correct answers, but by feeling their weight. Fortuitously, the technological shift that has disrupted the previous paradigm allows that commitment to be pursued without having the money or connections necessary to attend an “elite” institution. Circumstance no longer need prove an impossible obstacle, so long as one has the dedication.
2. Free Institutions
But neither can individuals simply find their way towards wisdom alone. The world of thought has a long history rife with complicated, even contradictory theses, on how one ought to understand reality. Even the brightest minds require interlocutors to develop well and to discover the truth. Thus, wealth and geographical proximity—historically, the two major impediments to educational opportunity—are decreasingly impediments; but a certain institutional environment remains necessary to adequate intellectual formation.
Friends, if truly dedicated to the mutual, shared pursuit of inquiry, form a kind of ad hoc institution. The serious person today may benefit greatly from joining reading groups united by common interest; or by enrolling in one of the new and rising online institutions, such as the Lyceum or the Albertus Magnus Institute. What makes these new ventures not only exciting and a great opportunity to learn, however, is that they provide a thoughtfully planned, ordered environment. Digital technology by itself can make information widely available, can allow us to communicate like never before; but facts and connections do not produce intellectual formation by default. Indeed, the proliferation of resources and unstructured environments may not only result in a superficial formation, but a fragmented one as well.
That a serious inquiry into an object leads to a real understanding requires an environment wherein that inquiry can truly live; unfold, that is, in its own due proper course. Thus it is that the new technological world grants educational institutions a new kind of freedom: namely, to keep open the doors of inquiry past two, four, or six years. Many serious questions do not ripen in such a short span. Further, most universities and colleges have long accepted the idea that their purpose is to prepare students for professional life: to give them credentials which signify their ability to be economically or civically productive. This becomes a mark of prestige for the university: “producing” graduates who “go on to do great things”. Maintaining this prestige comes to be a large part of the university’s own mission. Thus, there is an incentive to produce more and more clever students, faster and faster; thus to reward one mode of intelligence at the expense of all others. This keeps these institutions from acting freely.
But say, instead, that the expectation for a student is not that he or she will increase the institution’s prestige, but learn something; and that the something learned is not ordered to use in the world of work, but towards the goodness of life itself. Why should this be constrained to a time limit? That residential life in a serious environment of learning provides enormous benefits to the development of a mind cannot be doubted. But this is an increasingly rare privilege. Other opportunities are now open to us. We can build slow, patient, steady habits of intellectual depth. We can find friends who share our love for the truth no matter where we live. Academics, too, can be freed for the kind of thinking that belongs to a serious life—the kind of thinking that grows naturally, through dialogue, through encountering other minds hungry for truth’s eternal nourishment.
It seems inevitable, amidst these possibilities, that new institutions like the Lyceum will continue to form. Such institutions will not, of course, pop into being spontaneously, without deliberation about their structure or procedures. Mistakes will be made and disagreements will result in division. It will be difficult, as is always the case when the norms of life undergo a profound shift. But the conditions of digital connectivity and communication give us an opportunity to those in love with the life of the mind that cannot be ignored.
3. Signs of a New Class
How our new, freer institutions, will produce new fruits of intellectual life remains to be seen. They allow association of serious persons in a way entirely unlike anything before—without those constraints of time, place, or money. As these associations take shape, it is likely that they produce something more than ephemeral conversations. The intellectual life tends, that is, to leave a record of itself, to transmit its discoveries to others.
Modern academia has built (or, perhaps, distorted) this tendency into an industry. Anyone in academia has likely heard the mantra: “publish or perish”. Journal articles and monographs have proliferated, in consequence, containing legitimate and beneficial insights, but in what ultimately has been an intellectually unprofitable venture. I do not believe this is the path that new institutions will take. But neither do I think it will be the path of the blog post and the podcast, which are content productions of another kind.
Rather, I think the new intellectual class will yet produce written and other works of an enduring kind—but ones that follow from its own distinctive character of the slow and patient. The conversation of years, the inquiry conducted not through individual research but genuine dialectical practice: how does this translate into a public manifestation? What are the signs that this new intellectual culture will produce?
I do not know and I will not pretend to any certitude. But I believe there will be something distinctively communal about those signs. Cleverness is the mark of an individual mind. But one can reach a much greater depth through collaborative inquiry with others; each helping to dig deeper, to search more profoundly into the questions that belong to us by nature as human beings. A serious desire for understanding, that is, can bring people together in a way that mere admission into an “elite” institution cannot. A sophist and a fraud can find their way into institutions of the very highest repute. They might even rise to the top, therein. But their status comes from others’ recognition, in a vicious circle, of their status. It is an identity one puts on like a garment.
The new intellectual class, I think, will show itself by its participation in the common life of inquiry. This life grows not merely because its participants share virtues in common, but from the mutual recognition that what they are doing cannot be quantified, cannot be sold or traded; from the realization that this is what makes us most profoundly human.
[1] Focusing here, that is, on the U.S., and not identifying international competitors such as Oxford, Cambridge, Zurich, the Sorbonne, and so on.
[2] Arguably, in the age of social media, digital permeation, and generative AI, being highly-placed in the world tech may ultimately outpace the Ivy League and its competitors in terms of “elite status”.
[3] Marshall McLuhan 1964: Understanding Media, 465.


Leave a Reply